Is it Worth Doing an MBA? Part I

First, I have a disclosure to make. I have an MBA from MIT Sloan. I can’t say I had a fab time during these 2 years (far from it). I learnt a lot though – not only about business but also about myself. My professors and my classmates were great. Did it enhance my career? I am not sure. Am I happy to have done it? Definitely yes. Would I do it again? Possibly not.

When people come to me for advice whether to do an MBA or not, I am in a really awkward position. I don’t want to discourage them – the fact that they want to do an MBA (and all the sacrifices that come with it) shows they are ambitious. On the other hand, I want to tell them that the reality is not as rosy as it appears on the MBA brochures.

So, as an MBA graduate I decided to use a ‘tool’ to communicate this fine balance. It is called the SWOT analysis. This strategic planning method is used to evaluate the Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats involved in a business venture.

An MBA is a significant business venture (financed by you most of the times) and you need to do a thorough research before you embark on it.

Strengths: 

Is it worth doing an MBA? SWOT Analysis

Source: Wikipedia

  • You get general knowledge across various business topics
  • Your confidence increases from the minute you get accepted at top MBA (you immediately forget the other top schools that have rejected you)
  • You learn to ask the right questions
  • You get all the ‘tools’ you need to make a proper analysis (we love tools; five forces, 4Ps, SWOT analysis, etc)
  • It looks great on your resume
  • Your earning power will increase the minute you graduate

Weaknesses:

  • You are not an expert in anything.
  • You feel you are the best and all your co-workers hate you
  • Although you ask the right questions, you can rarely give the right answers
  • You hardly ever use these ‘tools’ in real life (unless you write blogs!)
  • On-the-job experience is more important
  • Those who go into investment banking skew the median salaries reported. Before you apply, take into consideration tuition fees, living expenses and opportunity cost

Opportunities:

  • It will boost your career
  • It will help you to make a career change
  • You will have a great network
  • It will open many doors

Threats:

  • Your future employer would like you to start from the lower ranks
  • If you graduate during a recession, you will be lucky to get back your old job
  • You stop being in touch with 90% of your classmates 2 years after graduation (For the remaining 10%, Thank God Linkedin and Facebook exist)
  • It will open a couple of doors only if you have gone to a top-tier MBA. Then, career progression will be purely based on your performance

Now that you have all these information, it is up to your to make a decision whether to do an MBA or not.

The bottom line: There is no doubt that you learn a lot from an MBA. There are many other ways to learn as well. If you decide to do one, I am certain you will ‘enjoy’ the journey. I can’t promise anything though about the destination.

Korina Karampela is the founder of b4iapply, author of 2 books, consultant and speaker. She has held senior executive positions in the pharmaceutical industry and has an MBA from MIT Sloan. Her b4iapply blog is among the professional development resources recommended by The Guardian.

This entry was posted in b4iapply for an MBA, Career Advice, Higher Education and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Is it Worth Doing an MBA? Part I

  1. Pingback: Top Five Articles of 2012 | b4iapply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s